v65nve7fdmmvliuewwdw.png
Project

Policy overview

Learn more about our proposed approach and how we got here.

VCS Social Value Leases

Haringey Council logo

Background 

Haringey Council is proud that its support helps Voluntary and Community Sector (VCS) groups to provide vital support to Haringey’s communities, particularly the most vulnerable. One of the ways in which we do this is by providing them with affordable premises for offices or other spaces from which to carry out their activities.  

 

There are many historic arrangements for how we provide these spaces, ranging from leases at zero or peppercorn rent to something closer to market rent. Many of the leases have expired and there is no formal policy or framework for determining the basis on which VCS organisations should occupy council-owned buildings. This leads to inconsistencies and the potential for accusations of unfair treatment, or at least a lack of transparency. It makes it unclear who has responsibility for building maintenance, and a number of the properties are in a poor state of repair.  

 

All of these issues cause problems for the groups, who may be unable to raise external funds because they do not have a secure or up to date lease, and the lack of resources and clear responsibility for maintenance means they are often working out of poor quality buildings.  

The same issues also cause problems for the council, which is unable to demonstrate the public benefit of letting the buildings to the VCS.  

 

Earlier this year Haringey Council cabinet agreed a report [Community Assets Policy report.pdf] committing to resolving this issue through a process of engagement with the voluntary and community sector. They agreed that an approach based on recognising the social value generated by VCS organisations in the borough should be developed and used to work out a subsidy to the market rent chargeable for a building to make it more affordable for charities and community groups. 

 

Social Value, as per the Social Value Act of 2012, encourages commissioners of public services to think about how they can secure wider social, economic and environmental benefits, not just the lowest cost of delivery. The National Themes, Outcomes & Measures (TOMs) framework for social value sets out four themes through which it can be measured: Community, Work, Economy, Planet. Our approach seeks to apply this thinking to the ways in which our community buildings and assets are used in the borough. 

 

 


Images of Markfield Park Adventure Playground (one of our early adopter organisations - see below)

What have we done since then? 

 

  • Worked with the Haringey Community Centre Network and held a workshop with their members on the 23 June to understand their concerns as current tenants of council-owned community centres, many without current leases, and hear what they want to see in a social value leasing arrangement 

 

  • Held a workshop with the wider voluntary and community sector on the 20 August to gain their inputs and ideas about what should be recognised through a social value measure and what their needs and issues are in relation to community assets and council-owned spaces  

 

  • Looked at what other Councils have done in trying to manage their community assets and voluntary sector leases to learn lessons from their approach 

 

  • Identified two early adopters to try out a possible social value matrix and see if it helps to identify the social value they are producing and to enable a discount to be calculated on the market value rent. The lessons from their experience will help determine the final policy and framework, alongside feedback through this survey. 

The two early adopters who we are working with to better understand how a social value subsidy might work in practice are Markfield and Hornsey Vale. These organisations both operate out of Council-owned buildings and we thank them for giving up their time to help us develop this policy. 

 

Where are we now? 

 

We have taken the feedback from the two workshops mentioned above and are using that to develop a new policy for calculating social value from community assets and how any rent subsidy should be calculated and applied. We now want to consult with the sector as part of this process of engagement on whether we have got the approach right and to gain feedback on how it could be improved. 

This consultation is scheduled to run from the 17th December 2024 to the 10th February 2025. 

 

Picture of members of HCCN standing alongside Haringey Council officers in a hall inside a Community Centre

How will the proposed social value subsidy work? 

Our proposed approach is that organisations would apply for a social value subsidy. This would be a reduction in the market rent that would otherwise be due for the building or asset that they want to occupy. They would do this by completing an initial self-assessment against a set of criteria, providing evidence of their constitution, purpose and management as an organisation, and how they are either already generating or propose to generate social value in the space provided. This would be reviewed by council officers from the Council’s VCS team to confirm the discount that can be applied.  

These social value criteria are what we would most like your feedback on, and we ask you to share your views about these in the 'Have Your Say' page. 

If the organisation is already operating, they will be able to provide their existing monitoring and annual reports as evidence. If they are newly constituted, the assessment would be against their business plan for the first year, with a review at month 9 of that year to confirm that they are delivering as intended so that the social value discount can continue in the subsequent year. 

Haringey Council’s property services team would carry out a property valuation to determine the market value of the rent, against which the subsidy would be applied once confirmed. They would additionally carry out the usual due diligence checks that they carry out on all prospective tenants to protect the council’s financial and legal interests. 

This policy and process would apply only to leases of council buildings or assets, not to ad hoc hires of portions of buildings for example hiring a room once a month to carry out an activity. There are agreed fees including reduced ‘community’ rates for hiring these spaces. 


Proposed Social Value Metrics

Haringey Council has identified and prioritised four principles as core to deciding whether community assets are delivering social value. These were developed through the VCS engagement workshops held during Summer 2024, and align to Haringey Council’s corporate priorities and outcomes. 

Our full policy would include examples of criteria to measure delivery on these principles, as well as a worked example to aid understanding.  

These four principles are:

1. Access (opening hours & inclusion): open when people want to use them, inclusive, and well-used by the local community  

2. Employment & skills: offering quality employment / volunteering opportunities including paying a London Living Wage to paid staff  

3. Social and community: delivering community activities, in particular: 

  • Preventing or reducing demand on statutory social care 

  • Supporting good mental and physical health  

  • Reducing loneliness and social isolation 

  • Providing opportunities for training and pathways into employment 

  • Providing opportunities and activities for young people 

  • Supporting families and vulnerable people with cost of living 

  • Providing homelessness advice and support 

  • Sharing and celebrating the many different cultures in our borough 

4. Environment & Sustainability: supporting the council’s efforts to tackle the climate emergency by developing sustainable policies and working practices  

Purple colour table containing the four social value criteria listed above alongside descriptive emojis

How much social value discount would be applied? 

The full policy would include a table indicating how many points an organisation would earn by successfully delivering on each metric (up to a total of 100). For instance, Social and Community might be worth up to 50 points. The policy would also include practical guidance on how we would expect an organisation to demonstrate its delivery on each metric, largely made up of documentation which we would expect organisations to already record. 

Our proposal is that an organisation scoring 100 on our social value matrix would qualify for a rental discount of 80% (the maximum discount to be given). A minimum score of 25 would provide a 20% discount. Scores below 25 would not qualify for a discount. 

Support can be accessed through the Haringey Community Collaborative to help an organisation develop its capacity and ability to qualify for a discount and therefore be able to take on a lease on a community asset. 

Hornsey Vale - one of our early adopter organisations

Why can the council not give a 100% discount? 

To ensure ongoing maintenance and repair of community buildings, the council asks all tenants to contribute towards these costs through their rent. Historically, many organisations paid minimal or no rent, which limited the Council’s ability to maintain these buildings to the standard both the council and tenants would wish to see. Given the increasingly challenging financial environment for local authorities, it is essential that we secure sufficient resources to manage and repair public assets throughout their lifespan. We also need to have sufficient internal resources to carry out the social value assessments and work alongside our commissioned capacity building partner, the Haringey Community Collaborative, to support this new process. 

We know that many organisations would have liked to have the option of a fully subsidised rent, but there is simply no fair and sustainable way to deliver this. 

Who would be eligible for a social value discount? 

We are proposing that only registered charities, community interest companies, co-operatives or other organisations where any surplus generated is clearly reinvested in the organisation’s social aims should be eligible to apply for a social value discount.  

We also propose that organisations must be registered in Haringey or have Haringey as a clear area of operation and benefit to be eligible to apply for a social value discount. 

Commercial organisations and paid membership organisations will not be eligible to apply for a social value discount. 

We want to target our social value-based support at those grassroots and smaller VCS organisations who need it most. We therefore propose to use the National Council for Voluntary Organisations definition of types of charitable organisations to propose that only organisations with a turnover of less than £1m per year (micro, small and medium size) would be eligible for a discount of more than 20%. Organisations with a turnover of £1m or more (large, major and above) would only be eligible for a maximum discount of 20%.

Decorative illustration of Haringey skyline

Discover more

hubrijfuvv1ym3buuiv9.jpg

Next steps

Find out what is happening next

Posted:
Read More
rm7eb4i4xqsrnyprjqs5.png
Closed

Shaping social value

Have your say on our proposed social value criteria

Project:VCS Social Value Leases

Stay Informed

Follow our projects to get notified of upcoming engagements and the latest project related news.