Consultation Closed
Our consultation on Subsidised Leases for VCS organisations has now closed. We would like to take this opportunity to thank you very much for your interest and engagement around this important issue.
VCS Social Value Leases
Our consultation on Subsidised Leases for VCS organisations has now closed.
We would like to take this opportunity to thank you very much for your interest and engagement around this important issue.
We will look at the findings in detail, but we wanted to provide a preliminary response to some of the biggest concerns that respondents expressed, as well as telling you how we will address them. These are:
- Affordability
- Repairs and Maintenance
- Trust in the Council to Deliver
- One-size-fits-all approach
Affordability
Based on some of the comments we received, many of you are concerned about affordability in relation to differing property values across the borough. We can reassure you that community leases operate in a slightly different way to commercial leases, and so-called market rent would be based mostly on the building’s unique qualities and proposed usage. It would be compared with other, similar, buildings in community use rather than pure land values or the price of residential property in the area. Variation in price is likely to be minimal, and we will elaborate on this further in the final policy.
Despite our difficult financial position, the Council is keen to support community centres and the broader VCS ecosystem. We are not seeking to sell well-used and valued community assets or to maximise the commercial income that could be generated, but we do need to take steps to ensure that these assets are cost neutral. The maximum subsidy level means we will have a pot of money dedicated to delivering the work outlined in this policy, as well as undertaking repairs and maintenance so that our community assets can be invested in and remain fit for purpose.
Repairs and Maintenance
This is connected to the question of affordability and maximum subsidies, as set out in the paragraph above.
We have heard loud and clear that many organisations are struggling to get repairs and maintenance conducted, whether from external providers or from the Council. We know that a big part of this is due to ambiguities in the lease around the division of responsibilities.
We have been discussing this in the context of our early adopter organisations and will work to ensure that responsibilities for repairs and maintenance are laid out clearly. We are also aware that it would be a major burden for a community group to have to find funds for major repairs such as heating systems, rewiring or a new roof. There is a connection between length of lease and level of capital responsibility taken on by tenants, and choices can be made by organisations when taking on a lease. We will set out options clearly in the final policy.
Trust in the Council to Deliver
The experts on this area are people who work in and run Community Centres, who we know have been involved in pieces of work like this before which have not been concluded. We really do understand where your concerns about delivery come from. But – to reassure you – we have never reached the stage of a cabinet decision before, and the sector, council officers and politicians have all expressed support for this approach, including on the record in the specific Cabinet report committing us to this approach last March and in the earlier broader Strategic Asset Management Property Improvement Plan.
This process has taken some time, but that is partly because we have sought to be thorough in our engagement with our partners and stakeholders, including you.
We look forward to being able to update you that this policy has been approved, and that we are getting to work on regularising leases, putting our Community Centres in the strongest possible position to deliver their services.
One-Size-Fits-All Approach
Community Centres, and VCS organisations, are hugely diverse – this is one of their strengths. We have sought to capture the diversity of activities delivered in our proposed social value matrix, particularly in the Social and Community section, which sets out a range of ways in which social value can be delivered, so that it is not a one-size-fits-all approach.
Where organisations are delivering specialised services, we will have further conversations to think about how we can recognise that in our approach to subsidised leases.
Our next steps are to:
- Review everything you have told us,
- Continue our engagement with Lead Members and our partner organisations Haringey Community Collaborative (HCC) and Haringey Community Centres Network (HCCN),
- Ensure all feedback is fully taken into account in our final policy proposal.
We plan to take a final policy to Cabinet for approval in April after which – assuming it is approved – the work of implementation will begin. As outlined in the Next Steps page, implementation would begin with the regularisation of leases for the Community Centres whose leases have expired.
Thank you once again for sharing your views.
Stay Informed
Follow our projects to get notified of upcoming engagements and the latest project related news.
