Project

Mythbusting: Common misconceptions about 20mph

We’ve sought to provide the facts behind common arguments.

Improving safety for Staple Hill residents

Mythbusting: Common misconceptions about 20mph

20mph speed restrictions can be controversial. Below we’ve set out some of the common arguments and the facts behind those arguments.

20mph limits cause congestion and increase travel times

20mph limits (especially on residential side roads) make a negligible difference to journey times. Delays are caused by congestion, traffic jams and constant stops. 

Achieving a constant speed of 30mph in built up areas is rare due to bends, junctions, obstacles etc. Therefore, travelling faster between obstructions only means extra waiting at the next stop.

Studies show congestion can be reduced with slower - but more consistent - speeds. Traffic flows through junctions more smoothly at lower speeds and slower speeds also result in fewer collisions which cause the lengthiest congestion issues.

20mph increases fuel consumption causing air pollution

30mph limits in built-up areas encourage faster acceleration and harsher braking between traffic lights and junctions. This means more emissions and higher fuel costs.

Many factors impact air quality, but 20mph limits on average offer 18% improvements in air quality and save drivers up to 7% in fuel costs.

One study has shown that under certain circumstances 30mph can use less fuel than 20mph - but this was only achievable in particular vehicles when they are driven continuously at 30mph for at least one kilometre - great if you have one of those cars and you’re travelling on a quiet country lane, but when was the last time you managed this in a busy built-up area?

The mechanics and physics are clear. Smoother driving to a lower limit requires less energy, less fuel and produces fewer emissions than repeatedly accelerating to a higher limit.

20's plenty road sign

You’d make a much bigger difference improving safety if you fixed the potholes in the roads

Potholes are a major safety concern, and one we take seriously, but we don’t have the funding to fix them all, so we need to consider alternative approaches.

20mph speed limits offer extremely good value for money when it comes to the safety benefits, compared to the cost.

20mph restrictions are only being introduced to raise money for South Gloucestershire Council from speeding fines

South Gloucestershire Council does not have powers to enforce speed limits and does not receive any income from speeding fines. Speeding fines are paid directly to central government.

It has been a disaster in Wales 

Some people point to the Welsh experience as a case study explaining their opposition to 20mph speed restrictions.

The change was controversial, attracting significant media coverage. But what is beyond doubt is the success of the scheme from a road safety perspective. In the first 18 months after the new speed limits were introduced, there was a 25% reduction in casualties on the roads compared to the previous 18 months.

This is almost as big an impact as when seat belts were made compulsory in front seats in 1983, which faced opposition at the time but is now widely accepted.

We also want to learn from what hasn’t worked so well. Before making changes, we are assessing all 30mph roads individually to identify where 20mph is suitable and will bring safety benefits.

No one wants it

Not true. Local communities are constantly asking the Council to tighten speed limits and do more to improve safety on our roads to protect their children and grandchildren. 

It can be quite difficult to measure the balance of opinion when media publications reflect a very narrow range of polarised headline-grabbing opinions and perceptions.

Two women walking on a residential street

It’s a waste of money

Given the current economic backdrop, the Council must ensure that every penny of our funding is spent wisely.

Area wide 20mph limits are highly cost effective. They are inexpensive to implement and even a small reduction in average speeds can have significant benefits for society at large.

Clearly, the main benefit is improved public safety and reducing the number of people being needlessly killed and seriously injured. There is clear evidence of reduced casualties from places where area-wide 20mph limits have been implemented. In Bristol, independent studies estimate that the 20mph restrictions they implemented 10 years ago have prevented on average, five people being killed and 11 people being seriously injured every year.

Beyond these incalculable benefits, 20mph limits are proven to improve quality of life by reducing fumes and noise and raise public health by reducing safety fears and encouraging active travel and physical exercise. 

Drivers in Wales have seen their insurance costs fall because of fewer accidents and claims.

When compared to alternative approaches, 20mph speed limits offer extremely good value for money.

20mph is fine outside a school, but it doesn’t need to be everywhere

20mph restrictions limited to small areas aren’t nearly as effective as broader schemes.

80% of child casualties happen on non-school trips, for example when they are walking or playing near where they live. 

People, especially those more vulnerable to higher speeds (older people are significantly more likely to die or be seriously injured than other groups when involved in a collision), need to be able to access shops, doctors and other facilities safely. 

Area-wide speed limits generally encourage more cycling and walking resulting in fewer car journeys, leading to healthier communities. Limited lower limits outside a school do not encourage this behaviour.

20mph restrictions are ineffective if they aren’t enforced

Most drivers do comply with speed limits, recognising the benefit in making the roads safer places to be.

Avon and Somerset Police are responsible for enforcing speed limits in South Gloucestershire. They can’t monitor every road all the time, but we support them in their enforcement work by helping to identify speeding hotspots.

20mph speed limits will not solve all speeding problems, but they're proven to reduce top speeds and improve safety.

To support them in their work, Avon and Somerset Police encourage local neighbourhoods to set up Community Speed Watch groups to help make motorists aware of the impact of speeding locally.

It is hard to drive at 20mph and distracting to watch the speedometer

People generally drive at speeds appropriate to road conditions and on residential roads included within the area wide 20mph proposal, we observe average speeds well below 30mph even without lower speed restrictions in place. These lower average speeds are due to the nature of junctions, parked vehicles, bends etc. 

Monitoring your speed should happen for any speed limit, especially in urban areas. Therefore, driving at a lower speed is no more distracting then at any other speed.

Area wide speed limits will also lead to widespread lower speeds meaning that driving at a lower speed becomes natural for motorists in built-up areas.


References and sources

Stay Informed

Follow our projects to get notified of upcoming engagements and the latest project related news.